This or That Game

[nadia101]

Alright you guys, this is a pretty basic game to play. If you don't know how to play, you're given a list a choices and pick one over the other. You MUST pick one or the other. I'm gonna purposely throw some tough ones to stump ya. Suggestions are always welcome, and I'll try to give you a new list weekly. So away we go....

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

It's a really fun game, just underline which one you prefer or something. You say why or not. There's going to be a new one every week.

Note: This is from Chrissy at DTM forums, so thank you to her!! :)

[IDressInGold]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke

2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo

3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris <--Boo to both! But, as friends only!

4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere

5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy

6. Brooke with OR without bangs

7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel

8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe

9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas

10. Karen with Andy OR Keith

11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas

12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke

13. James' hair long OR buzzed <--mmmm, James hair...

14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas

15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around <--Dude, they're on a freaking car the second time!

16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of
Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone

17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls

18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2 <--Hay, hay, Halo!

19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers

20. Jake: come back OR stay away <--I heart me some BG.

[naley_4ever]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris <--- ewww to both, but just as friends, Nathan and Taylor
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere <--- tough one..
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel <--- the fight in WIAWSNB was awesome
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe <---tough one..
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas <---neither.. but the early season 3 Peyton annoyed me so..
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around <---haven't seen the second time around yet so I'll have to go with..
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone 17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2 <---Halo!
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[XiUca]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
*Nathan and Haley!! of course ;)
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
*Haley's tattoo. It has a meaning, it's romantic!
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
*man... i hate both options, but i'd say Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
*S2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
*Fall Out Boy!!
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
*Without.
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
*Peyton vs. Nikki
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
*Tric!
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
*Nathan and Haley.
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
*Andy
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
*Sometimes Lucas annoys me, he's perfect all the time, always the nice guy...
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
*Rachel!
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
*buzzed! But long is good too! he's all good!
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
*Nathan and Haley!
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
*1st kiss, i didn't saw the second time..
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
*A new cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
*Keith
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
*Vol. 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
*the younger! of course!
20. Jake: come back OR stay away
*Come back!!!

[Katie]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[Danizinha]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris...As everyone said, neither, but as friends.
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith I also liked Andy, though.
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around :lol: Damn that was hard to choose.
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[Trina]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris<----I love Haley/Chris!
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel<---- They are great together.Enemies or friends.
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas<----Neither but since I had to choose.
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith<----of course!!!!
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke<---But I still love her.
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls<---- so much funnier!
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake:come back OR stay away<----Lucas and Peyton are together now, so I dont want him comming back.

I wanted to edit mine, because my ships have changed, and so have what I picked

[Sonni]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris [I dislike Taylor and Chris, since I love Naley, but I'll go with Haley/Chris]
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[Chloe/Clark]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith --- dude!
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas (atleast his hair is)
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away (I like him, just not with Peyton)

[Leliy]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

OMG; There were some up here that I was just :eek:

[Kate]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[brucasforever]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[gel Ü]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel (peyton kicked her *ss:ninja: )
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas (none! :lol:)
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas (none! :))
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2 (both!)
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[Fading Shadow]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke:Nathan/Haley
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo:Haley's
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris:Nathan with Taylor
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere:Season 1 finale
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy:Both
6. Brooke with OR without bangs:With
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel:Brooke vs Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe:Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas:Nathan/Haley
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith:Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas:Neither
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke:Rachel
13. James' hair long OR buzzed:Buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas:Nathan/Haley
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around:Second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone:A can of Sunkist
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls:The three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2:Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers:Both
20. Jake: come back OR stay away:Come back

[Marissa]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke: Nathan/Haley
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo: Luke's
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris: Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere: Season 1 finale
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy: Fallout Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs: With
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel: Brooke vs Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe: TRiC
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas: Nathan/Haley
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith: Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas: Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke: Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed: Buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas: Nathan/Haley
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around: Second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone: A can of Sunkist
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls: The three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2: Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers: Older
20. Jake: come back OR stay away: STAY AWAY !

[Kristen]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

[Lily]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas i can't believe i voted anything BL *sigh*
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone hahahahaha
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

since in Nadia's original post she said that there would be new questions 'every week' if no one has any objections i might start compiling a new list?

[CamyWinchester]

1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away

And yea, start a new one. This is old

[brucasforever]

since in Nadia's original post she said that there would be new questions 'every week' if no one has any objections i might start compiling a new list?
yeah I think that's a good idea :)

[Kristen]

Yeah thats a good idea, whos going ot do it?


Who can be here everyweek?

We should make it 2 people just incase.

[sarahyeager]

i just wanted to do this before a new one was started. =]]


1. Nathan and Haley OR Lucas and Brooke
2. Haley's tattoo OR Lucas' tattoo
3. Nathan with Taylor OR Haley with Chris <friends only. loved their songs and he started her singing right? haha
4. Season 1 finale OR Season 2 premiere
5. Better Musical guest: Jimmy Eat World OR Fall Out Boy
6. Brooke with OR without bangs
7. Peyton vs. Nikki OR Brooke vs. Rachel
8. Where would you rather hang out? Tric OR Karen's Cafe
9. Most Anticipated Reunion: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
10. Karen with Andy OR Keith
11. More annoying: Peyton OR Lucas <-- niether but lucas kindof annoyed me when he was with Anna
12. More slutty: Rachel OR Brooke
13. James' hair long OR buzzed
14. Better kiss in the rain: Nathan/Haley OR Brooke/Lucas
15. Nathan/Haley's first kiss in the rain OR the second time around <--on the car? SO HOT.
16. Which would you rather buy after watching an episode of OTH: A can of Sunkist OR a new Cingular phone
17. Better jailbird: Keith OR the three girls
18. OTH Soundtrack: Volume 1 OR Volume 2
19. The younger OR the older Scott brothers
20. Jake: come back OR stay away<-- love leyton to death, but i wouldn't mind a little jeyton controversy. =]]

[Lily]

QUESTIONS: Volume Two
attempting to update a little....

1) Better girl for Mouth: Gigi or Shelley
2) Better friendship: Haley/Brooke or Haley/Peyton
3) Most un-realistic storyline: Brooke's fashion line or Peyton's FOB romance
4) Place you'd hang: Karen's Cafe or Deb's Diner
5) Which Derek: Psycho!Derek or Real!Derek
6) Chad/Lucas's hair: season 2 or season 4
7) Better group episode: 2.05 I Will Dare or 4.17 It Gets the Worst at Night
8) Better teen father: Jake or Nathan
9) Season 3 finale or Season 4 premiere
10) Better Guest Star: Tyler Hilton as Chris Keller or Steven Colletti as Chase Adams
11) Meant to be: Leyton or Brucas
12) Better prom dress: Haley or Brooke or Peyton (yes, there's 3, coming up with questions is tough)
13) Better dance: Mouth/Peyton 'disco inferno' or Mouth/Skills/Nathan 'strip club'
14) Dan impregnating Karen or Deb
15) Which uncle do you miss more: Keith Scott or Hot Uncle Cooper
16) Peyton's podcasts or Lucas's voiceover quotes
17) Better Tagarro sibling: Felix or Anna
18) Who is the better character introduced in 3.16: Glenda or Abby
19) Karen/Dan or Karen/Keith
20) Skipping forward 4 years for season 5: yay or nay


if you find any of the questions to be thoroughly ridiculous, let me know and i'll change 'em :D otherwise enjoy....

[Marissa]

1) Better girl for Mouth: Gigi or Shelley
2) Better friendship: Haley/Brooke or Haley/Peyton
3) Most un-realistic storyline: Brooke's fashion line or Peyton's FOB romance
4) Place you'd hang: Karen's Cafe or Deb's Diner
5) Which Derek: Psycho!Derek or Real!Derek
6) Chad/Lucas's hair: season 2 or season 4
7) Better group episode: 2.05 I Will Dare or 4.17 It Gets the Worst at Night
8) Better teen father: Jake or Nathan
9) Season 3 finale or Season 4 premiere
10) Better Guest Star: Tyler Hilton as Chris Keller or Steven Colletti as Chase Adams
11) Meant to be: Leyton or Brucas
12) Better prom dress: Haley or Brooke or Peyton (yes, there's 3, coming up with questions is tough)
13) Better dance: Mouth/Peyton 'disco inferno' or Mouth/Skills/Nathan 'strip club'
14) Dan impregnating Karen or Deb
15) Which uncle do you miss more: Keith Scott or Hot Uncle Cooper
16) Peyton's podcasts or Lucas's voiceover quotes
17) Better Tagarro sibling: Felix or Anna
18) Who is the better character introduced in 3.16: Glenda or Abby
19) Karen/Dan or Karen/Keith
20) Skipping forward 4 years for season 5: yay or nay

LOVED em katie!!!

[Lily]

yay! i'm glad, i was worried...

1) Better girl for Mouth: Gigi or Shelley
2) Better friendship: Haley/Brooke or Haley/Peyton
3) Most un-realistic storyline: Brooke's fashion line or Peyton's FOB romance
4) Place you'd hang: Karen's Cafe or Deb's Diner
5) Which Derek: Psycho!Derek or Real!Derek (tough love and a man in uniform all rolled into a tidy package!
6) Chad/Lucas's hair: season 2 or season 4
7) Better group episode: 2.05 I Will Dare or 4.17 It Gets the Worst at Night
8) Better teen father: Jake or Nathan
9) Season 3 finale or Season 4 premiere
10) Better Guest Star: Tyler Hilton as Chris Keller or Steven Colletti as Chase Adams
11) Meant to be: Leyton or Brucas
12) Better prom dress: Haley or Brooke or Peyton (yes, there's 3, coming up with questions is tough)
13) Better dance: Mouth/Peyton 'disco inferno' or Mouth/Skills/Nathan 'strip club'
14) Dan impregnating Karen or Deb
15) Which uncle do you miss more: Keith Scott or Hot Uncle Cooper
16) Peyton's podcasts or Lucas's voiceover quotes
17) Better Tagarro sibling: Felix or Anna
18) Who is the better character introduced in 3.16: Glenda or Abby
19) Karen/Dan or Karen/Keith
20) Skipping forward 4 years for season 5: yay or nay