This or that #2

[Crashdown mommy]

from the last thread it was Prue

[Little Alien]

lol E, you forgot to post one!!!

phoebe as a mermaid, or phoebe as a banshee?

[Heather]

mermaid

Leo or Dan?

[GoodbyeAngel]

Leo; cuz she and him make cute kids together

Paige as a social work or a full time witch?

[Crashdown mommy]

full time witch

prue or page

[Kay]

Prue

Phoebe with or Cole or with Jason?!?

[nathanfan]

cole.....



piper mourning prues death in hell hath no fury or the one with her funeral (cant remeber the name) ah

[Kay]

Piper mourning prues death in hell hath no fury

Piper and Leo dating or married?!?

[nathanfan]

dating.. so more lovey dovey....



wyatt or chris

[Kay]

Chris!

Pipers reaction to Chris being her son or Paiges?!?

[nathanfan]

pipers it was like.. whoa. ahaah

leo's reaction to chris being his son or pipers

[Crashdown mommy]

Leo's it was to funny
Evil chris & Leo or good chris & leo

[nathanfan]

evil.. sooo hotttt..

evil barbas or good barbas

[Malfoy]

Evil Barbas

demons or banshees?

[Patti Jo]

demons

The Manor's Kitchen (where all the potions are brewed)
or
The Manor's Attic (where "The Book" resides.)

[Kay]

Attic

P3 or The manor?

[Malfoy]

The manor

Leo or Cole?

[Kay]

Leo

Chris or Wyett?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Aww, that's hard! They're both cutee! But I'm gonna say Wyatt--cause Chris wouldn't even be there if it weren't for him :)

Piper/Leo or Phoebe/Cole?

[Malfoy]

Phoebe/Cole

Prue/Cole or Paige/Cole?

[Kay]

Paige/Cole

Pheobe/jason or Prue/Andy?

[Syd Bristow]

Prue/Andy

Redhead Paige or Brunette Paige?

[Kay]

Brunette

Prue or Paige?!?

[Syd Bristow]

both! okay, Prue.

Andy or Dan?

[Kay]

Andy

Chris or leo?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Leo

Evil Cole or Good Cole?

[Malfoy]

Evil Cole

Julian or Brian?

[Kay]

Brian

Alyssa or Brian?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Brian

Alyssa or Phoebe?

[Malfoy]

Phoebe

Showing Phoebe smoking on screen- acceptable or bad idea?

[Kay]

acceptable

making the Charmed ones more real or not?!?
{liek showing them shopping, drinking, partying, etc}

[Malfoy]

making them more real

Paige to have another serious relationship this season- yes or no?

[Syd Bristow]

yeah

Do you want Darryl to help out the sisters this season or still be mad at them?

[Kay]

help the sisters!

Should Darryl die or just leave?!?

[Syd Bristow]

leave (cause then there's the possibility of him coming back!)

Darryl or Andy?

[Malfoy]

Darryl

Darryl/Piper or Darryl/Phoebe?

[Kay]

Darryl/Phoebe

Darryl/Prue or Darryl/Paige?!?

[Malfoy]

Darryl/Paige

Paige or Prue?

[Syd Bristow]

Prue

Prue/Phoebe's relationship w/one another, or Piper/Phoebe's relationship?

[Malfoy]

Piper/Phoebe

Better family relationship: Piper & Paige or Phoebe & Paige?

[Kay]

Phoebe & Paige

better sister Pheobe or Piper?

[Malfoy]

Piper

Better sister: Prue or Paige?

[Kay]

Prue

better actress Shannon or Rose?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Shannon

better actor - Brian Krause or Julian McMahon?

[Kay]

Brian Krause

Pheobe/Jason or Pheobe/Cole?!?

[Malfoy]

Phoebe/Cole

Shannen should've left- yes or no?

[Syd Bristow]

no :(

The power of Four: Prue, Piper, Phoebe, Paige--all in the show at once, yes or no?

[Kay]

No, that would change the whole story line!!

The first Three or the second three?!?

[Syd Bristow]

the First 3

Baby Wyatt or Baby Chris?

[Kay]

Baby Wyatt {saw more of him}

cute-est:- Older Wyett or Older Chris?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Older Chris

Leo or Paige?

[Kay]

Leo

Prue/Piper or Pheobe/Piage?!?

[Malfoy]

Phoebe/Paige

Prue and Paige sould meet- yes or no?

[Kay]

Yes

Andy dying..good or bad?!?

[Syd Bristow]

bad

Should Cole have died?

[Kay]

ermm..yes

Sadest- Cole or Andys death!??

[Malfoy]

Cole's death

Prue/Andy or Phoebe/Cole?

[Kay]

Prue/Andy

Prue/Andy or Piper/Dan?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Prue/Andy

Prue/Andy or Piper/Leo?

[Malfoy]

Piper/Leo

Charmed fanlistings or Charmed cliques?

[Kay]

Charmed fanlistings I guess

Pheobe/jason or Piper/dan?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Phoebe/Jason

Phoebe/Leo or Piper/Cole? ;)

[Kay]

hmm..Phoebe/Leo [I dont like Cole]

Leo/Prue or Leo/Paige?

[Syd Bristow]

Leo/Prue

Piper/Jason or Phoebe/Dan

[Malfoy]

Phoebe/Dan

Phoebe/Leo or Paige/Leo?

[Kay]

Phoebe/Leo

hang out with Piper or Pheobe?!?

[Malfoy]

Phoebe

Next sister to run P3- Phoebe or Paige?

[Kay]

Phoebe

next sister to die Piper or Pheobe?

[Syd Bristow]

Aww what a sad thought! :( Lol...ummm, Phoebe because Piper has Leo and a family to raise! It'd be awful for the kids to grow up w/no mother. I would feel SOOO bad for Leo if Piper died!

Older Chris to come back, yes or no?

[Malfoy]

yes

Hotter- Drew or Julian?

[Kay]

Drew

Chris & wyett to be friends or not!??

[Syd Bristow]

yeah! :)

More excited to see on Charmed --> Nick Lachey, Charisma Carpenter, or Kerr Smith?

[Kay]

Kerr Smith

S7: can't wait or can?!?

[Syd Bristow]

we already have it here, but i cant wait for the next ep! :D

Who would you rather guest star on Charmed as students from Magic School - the cast of One Tree Hill, or the cast of the OC?

[Kay]

thats one hard question :lol:...I'll have to pick OTH for shallow reason :(

Have a band guest-star or one of the sisters become a singer for an ep.?

[Syd Bristow]

If you mean by become a famous singer or something than I'd rather one of the sisters become a singer for an ep.

Phoebe's wardrobe or Piper's?

[Kay]

Phoebe's

spending a day with Pheobe or Paige?

[freakygirl]

phoebe
phoebe/jason or phoebe/leslie

[Kay]

phoebe/jason...[I havnt seen leslie yet & I :heart: her with Jason]

Prue/Andy or Prue/Jack?!?

[Malfoy]

Prue/Jack

Piper/Dan or Piper/Leo?

[Kay]

Piper/Leo

Leo vs Dan or Leo vs Chris?!

[Syd Bristow]

Leo vs Dan--both loved Piper, both fought for her, very funny.
plus I love it when Leo and Chris get along!

Piper vs Paige (when Paige first arrived) or Phoebe vs Prue (when Phoebe 1st came back)

[Kay]

Phoebe vs Prue

Pheobe/Piper or Piper/Prue?

[jakesnumba1gal]

Piper/Prue

Alyssa or Shannen?

[Kay]

Alyssa

Paige or Prue?

[Malfoy]

Paige

next to guest star should be Chad Michael Murray or James Lafferty?

[Syd Bristow]

oooh....hard one, ummmm CMM (maybe he'd be able to pick up one of the girls :lol: )

Jack (sheridan) or Dan?

[Kay]

dan

Chris or leo?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Leo! :)

Chris or Cole?

[Kay]

Chris

Chris & Leo or Chris & Piper?!?

[freakygirl]

Chris & Piper

wyatt/leo or chris/leo

[Syd Bristow]

Chris/Leo (older Chris, that is)

Chris/Phoebe or Chris/Paige?

[Kay]

Chris/Phoebe

Wyett/Prue or Chris/Prue?!?

[freakygirl]

Wyett/Prue (i think older wyatt would've bonded more with prue)

P3 or bay mirror

[Kay]

P3

Pheobe job or Pipers [the one at P3]

[Syd Bristow]

Piper's

Phoebe's job or Paige's old job?

[Kay]

Phoebe

Potions [sp?] or spells?!?

[Syd Bristow]

spells

Prue or Phoebe?

[Kay]

Pheobe

Pheobe or Piper?

[Syd Bristow]

Piper

Andy or Cole?

[Kay]

Andy

Chris or Cole?!?

[Syd Bristow]

Chris

Would you rather be an elder or a whitelighter?

[Kay]

white-lighter

a witch or whitelighter

[Sweet Misery]

witch

Witch or Demon

[freakygirl]

witch

demon or warlock

[Kay]

Demon

Cole :- evil or good?

[Syd Bristow]

gooood

evil Cole or evil Phoebe?

[Sweet Misery]

evil Phoebe

Prue with Black hair or with Blonde hair

[Syd Bristow]

Black Hair

S1 Phoebe or S7 Phoebe?

[Sweet Misery]

S7 Phoebe

Season one Piper or Season 7 Piper

[P!NK]

Season 7 Piper

Coolest new guy.
Lesley or Agent Brody?

[Sweet Misery]

Lesley

Andy or Morus (SP?)

[Kay]

Andy

Andy/Prue or Piper/Dan?

[freakygirl]

Andy/Prue

dan come back for a ep or not

[Syd Bristow]

not (though it would be interesting)

Most energetic sister - Phoebe, Paige, Piper, or Prue?

[Sweet Misery]

Phoebe

Piper as a blond or Red Head

[Kay]

red head

Piper as a mom or sister?

[Syd Bristow]

Umm, Mom i guess cause it's cute seeing her with Chris & Wyatt

Phoebe with blonde hair or with brown hair?

[Kay]

brown

pheobe with short or long hair?

[Sweet Misery]

short

Piper with Leo or Phoebe with Leo

[Kay]

Piper with Leo

prue/andy or cole/phepbe?

[nathanfan]

prue/andy!!!!!

Hell Hath No Fury or Charmed Again Part 1

[HyPerWBTVMnky]

Charmed Again Pt. 1

Seasons 1-3 or Seasons 4+

[Sweet Misery]

Seasons 1-3

piper season 4 or 7

[HyPerWBTVMnky]

Piper season 7, she's so motherly

Jason or Les?

[Sweet Misery]

Jason

Evil Piper or Evil Prue

[Syd Bristow]

Evil Prue

Andy or Darryl?

[Sweet Misery]

Andy

Prue, Piper, Phoebe Or Prue, Phoebe, Paige

[HyPerWBTVMnky]

Prue Piper Phoebe

demons or witches?

[Sweet Misery]

witches

Prue and Andy or Piper and Leo

[Syd Bristow]

Piper & Leo

Piper now, or Piper in the early seasons?

[Kay]

erm..in earllier seasons!

Piper with her Family or sisters?

[Syd Bristow]

Aww that's tough! I'm gonna say her family, they need her more.

Phoebe/Piper rivalry or Piper/Paige rivalry?

[Sweet Misery]

Piper/Paige rivalry

Paige as a whitelighter or as a sister

[WitchsFamiliar]

Paige as a sister...

Leo as a whitelighter or an elder?

[Little Alien]

Whitelighter. He's gone all insane since becoming an elder lol.

Piper as a wendigo or Piper as a werewolf ?

[WitchsFamiliar]

Piper as a werewolf...

Let's see, Piper before being a mother or after?

[Kenora H. Saul]

before, she was more interesting.

Phoebe w/ a kid or w/o one?

[CharmingAngel]

Deff with a kid!

Old P3 or New P3

[WitchsFamiliar]

New P3

Leo now or Leo in the sixties?

[CharmingAngel]

Deff hottie Leo now!

Prue or Paige

[Chloe/Clark]

PRUE!

Phoebe or Paige?

[Kenora H. Saul]

Phoebe.

Andy or Daryl?

[CharmingAngel]

Andy... Daryl is a meanie these days.

Full Witch or Half Witch/Half Whitelighter

[Kenora H. Saul]

full witch.

chris or wyatt?

[WitchsFamiliar]

Chris

Witch or Warlock?

[Kenora H. Saul]

witch.

Elders or Avatars?

[NaleyFan4ever]

Elders

Piper or Paige?

[CharmingAngel]

Piper

TK or TKO

[Kenora H. Saul]

TKO.

Cole or Leo?

[WitchsFamiliar]

Leo hands down.....


Cole or Andy?

[Chloe/Clark]

Andy, I never liked Cole :P

Piper w/ Leo or w/o Leo?

[CharmingAngel]

R u kidding me? Piper WITH mah man Leo offcourse! Hello! Dreamcouple here! ;)

Pan or Pleo? (Dan/Piper or Leo/Piper)

[Kenora H. Saul]

Pleo;)

Season 2 or Season 6?

[CharmingAngel]

Hmmmm *thinks hard* Season 2 had Prue which I didn't/don't like... so I have to say S6!

S1 or S2

[rachelfan88]

S1

Paige in S4 or S7

[CharmingAngel]

Paige in S7

S2 or S3

[WitchsFamiliar]

S2

Paige when she first joined or Paige now?

[CharmingAngel]

Paige now :)

Paige the witch or Paige the whitelighter

[Little Alien]

Paige the witch.
I dont think Paige would make a very good whitelighter, she hardly ever takes the initiative and heals anyone.

Past Phoebe's power of fire-throwing, or Past Prue's power of ice breath?

[Chloe/Clark]

Ice power, much LESS evil.. And Paige dosn't heal anyone cuz she can't without assistant as Chris coudn't...

Future Prue's hair or Piper's future hair? (morality bites)

[mckenzies#1fan]

Piper's future hair.


Phoebe blonde or brunette?

[WitchsFamiliar]

Phoebe brunette

Paige brunette or redhead?

[Chloe/Clark]

brunette, without a doubt

Phoebe and Cole or Phoebe and Coop?

[WitchsFamiliar]

Phoebe and Cole

Cole as a demon or Cole as the Source

[rachelfan88]

As a demon

Phoebe or Paige?

[Chloe/Clark]

Paige

Prue and Cole or Phoebe and Leo?

[Faith]

Pheobe and Leo

Pheobe/Coop or Pheobe/Cole?

[mckenzies#1fan]

Phoebe/Cole true love forever


Grams or Penny?